Home > Compare > vs Virayo

Honest Comparison

DerivateX vs Virayo: 12 Years of SaaS SEO vs an AI-First Approach

Virayo has 12+ years of exclusively B2B SaaS SEO experience, strong revenue-attributed case studies, and the credibility of co-founder Robbie Richards. They recently added AI search to their positioning. Here is an honest look at where they lead, where the gap is, and how to choose.

Get Your Free AI Visibility Audit View All Comparisons

At a Glance

Side-by-Side Comparison

Dimension	Virayo	DerivateX
Focus	B2B SaaS exclusively	B2B SaaS exclusively
Track Record	12+ years (founded 2012)	Newer, AI-era native
Google SEO	Strong ($2.8M ARR for SPOTIO)	Strong (pipeline focused)
GEO / AI Search	New addition (recently rebranded)	Core methodology (Citation Engineering)
AI Revenue Proof	No	Yes (Gumlet ~20% revenue)
AI Visibility Tracking	No equivalent published	Weekly AVS (0-100 score)
Pricing	$6,000-$30,000/mo (published)	$5,000+/mo
Commitment	6-month minimum recommended	6-12 month engagements
Clutch	11 reviews, highly rated	5.0 rating, 7 reviews
Notable Clients	SPOTIO, ForUsAll, Cedreo, Truckstop	Gumlet, REsimpli, Verito

About Virayo

Who Virayo Is

Virayo is a B2B SaaS SEO agency founded in 2012 in Boise, Idaho. Co-founded by Robbie Richards, a well-known SEO blogger and practitioner, Virayo has 12+ years of exclusively B2B SaaS SEO experience and has served 85+ SaaS clients.

They recently rebranded to include AI search in their positioning: "B2B agency for SEO and AI search (AEO, GEO)." Their homepage now mentions AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini visibility. They have an "integrated discovery framework" that includes G2, third-party listicles, video carousels, and AI mentions.

Their case studies are the strongest traditional SEO proof in this comparison: SPOTIO generated 1,700+ demos and $2.8M new ARR from organic. ForUsAll grew SQLs from 20 to 120 per month while cutting ad spend 90%. Cedreo grew organic traffic from 6K to 70K+ with trial signups up 7x. Pricing starts at $6,000/month with a 6-month minimum recommended.

Founded2012, Boise, Idaho

Co-founderRobbie Richards (SEO practitioner)

FocusB2B SaaS exclusively

Clients85+ B2B SaaS (SPOTIO, ForUsAll, Cedreo)

Pricing$6,000-$30,000/month (published)

Commitment6-month minimum recommended

Clutch11 reviews, highly rated

GEORecently added, not core methodology

Where Virayo Excels

What Virayo Does Well

Virayo has the longest SaaS SEO track record on this comparison list. Their strengths are real, proven over 12+ years of exclusively serving B2B SaaS companies.

12+ Years of SaaS SEO

The longest track record of any agency in this comparison. Virayo has been exclusively B2B SaaS since 2012. That depth of experience is genuine and hard to replicate.

Revenue-Attributed Case Studies

SPOTIO: $2.8M new ARR from organic, 1,700+ demos. ForUsAll: SQLs from 20 to 120/month. These are not traffic metrics. They are pipeline and revenue outcomes.

Robbie Richards Brand

Co-founder Robbie Richards is a respected SEO practitioner and blogger. His personal brand adds credibility and signals genuine expertise in the SaaS SEO space.

Consultative Sales Process

Clutch reviews praise Virayo for a consultative approach with no fluff. They are clear on strategy before execution starts and transparent about what they can and cannot deliver.

Transparent Pricing

Pricing starts at $6,000/month and scales to $30,000 for enterprise. Published on their website. Month-to-month with 30-day opt-out after the initial recommended 6-month period.

Demos, Trials, ARR Focus

Virayo tracks demos, trial signups, and ARR, not vanity traffic. Their reporting connects SEO execution to the business outcomes that matter. This is the right approach.

The Gap

Virayo's AI Search Positioning Is New, Not Core

Virayo recently updated their homepage to include "AI search (AEO, GEO)" alongside their traditional SEO positioning. This is a rebrand, not a rebuild. Their AI search offering appears to be emerging rather than established. Here are the specific gaps.

GEO is a recent addition, not the core methodology

Virayo's AI search positioning is new. Their 12+ years of case studies are all traditional Google SEO outcomes. The AI search capability appears to be bolted onto a strong existing foundation rather than built as a native layer.

No named AI search methodology

"Integrated discovery framework" mentions G2, listicles, video, and AI mentions. But there is no named, published methodology equivalent to Citation Engineering. The steps, measurement, and attribution framework are not defined publicly.

No AI citation tracking or AVS equivalent

No published measurement methodology for AI search visibility. No weekly tracking of citation frequency across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini. No AI Visibility Score. The AI channel is untracked.

No documented AI revenue attribution

Virayo's impressive case studies (SPOTIO $2.8M, ForUsAll 6x SQL growth) are all Google SEO outcomes. None show AI search citations connected to pipeline or revenue. Their AI channel has no published proof yet.

Higher minimum and less flexibility

$6,000/month minimum with a 6-month recommended engagement. For companies at $1M to $5M ARR, this combined with the lack of proven AI capability may not justify the spend versus an agency that delivers both channels from day one.

Where DerivateX Wins

What DerivateX Offers That Virayo Does Not (Yet)

Virayo may develop strong AI search capability over time. Today, the gap is methodology depth and proven AI outcomes. Here is what DerivateX delivers that Virayo does not.

AI-First, Not AI-Added

DerivateX was built for the AI search era from day one. Citation Engineering is the core methodology, not a recent addition to an existing service. Every process, tool, and measurement was designed for AI visibility alongside Google SEO.

Named, Published GEO Methodology

Citation Engineering: Entity Clarity, Citation Building, Authority Signals, AI Visibility Tracking, Pipeline Attribution. Defined steps, repeatable process, measurable outcomes. Not "integrated discovery" framing.

Weekly AI Visibility Score

AVS tracks citation frequency across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Claude every sprint. Score from 0 to 100. Virayo has no equivalent AI-specific measurement methodology published.

Documented AI Revenue Attribution

Gumlet: approximately 20% of inbound revenue tracked to AI discovery via CRM pipeline data. Virayo's case studies are all traditional SEO outcomes. The AI revenue proof does not exist in their portfolio yet.

The Verdict

When to Choose Virayo vs DerivateX

Choose Virayo if: You value a long track record (12+ years) and the credibility of the Robbie Richards brand. You have a larger budget ($6K-$30K/month), prioritize proven Google SEO case studies with revenue attribution, and are willing to accept that AI search is an emerging capability in their offering rather than a core one.

Choose DerivateX if: You need an agency built for the AI search era from the start. You want a named GEO methodology with weekly AI tracking and documented AI revenue attribution. You need both Google SEO and AI visibility in one engagement with proven outcomes in both channels. You are in the $1M to $20M ARR range and want focused depth at an accessible price.

The core distinction: Virayo's traditional SaaS SEO credentials are excellent. Their AI search positioning is new and lacks the same depth of methodology and proof. DerivateX was built AI-first. If you need proven AI search outcomes today, not a promise that they are being developed, DerivateX is the choice.

More Comparisons

See for Yourself

Find Out If Your SEO Agency's AI Claims Hold Up

We will run your brand through 50+ buyer prompts across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Claude. You will see your real AI visibility baseline, not a promise that it is being worked on.

Get Your Free AI Visibility Audit